How do you spend money on a new car when you repair an accident car?
Shandong commercial newspaper reporter Wang Qian
collision of the same model of two cars, the traffic police identified the two sides of the same responsibility. One party will remove the car from its own car repair factory, and open the maintenance fee of the vehicle, let the other repair plant seal, and the final maintenance fee can be bought for a new car. When the client asked for compensation from the appraisal report, the judge found out that he was too tired to dismiss his request for prosecution.
in February of this year, Zhao Hai's vehicle collided with the same type of car that Liu Xiaoliang drove. The traffic police brigade of Shanghe County Public Security Bureau issued a road traffic accident confirmation that Zhao Hai and Liu Xiaoliang assumed the same responsibility for the accident. After the accident, Zhao Hai brought Liu Xiaoliang husband and wife and accident vehicle underwriting insurance company to court. The loss of Zhao Haicheng's own vehicle was 54000 yuan, which required the insurance company to bear 2000 yuan within the limit of the insurance coverage, the remaining part was 26000 yuan by 50% by Liu Xiaoliang, and the appraisal fee of 1500 yuan, and a total of 29500 yuan. This means that the defendant has to pay 28000 yuan for vehicle maintenance and 1500 yuan for appraisal fees.
in the face of Zhao Hai's request for prosecution, the defendant said he did not recognize it. Because in this accident, the small car driven by Zhao Hai is mainly damaged by the left front part, and the maintenance cost he issued is as high as 54000 yuan. Zhao Hai's vehicle purchase time is in 2011, the vehicle purchase price is about 80000 yuan, the vehicle use time has reached more than three years, the vehicle value has been greatly derogatory, the vehicle market has basically stopped selling, and the market price of the new series of vehicles is about fifty thousand or sixty thousand yuan. Not particularly serious damage. How can the maintenance cost catch up with the price of the new car? The appraisal report issued by Zhao Hai drew the attention of the judge.
it is understood that in the appraisal report issued by the accreditation agency submitted by Zhao Hai, the record is the damaged insurance mark on the site of the Shanghe Traffic Police Brigade parking lot and the Hongyun automobile maintenance plant. The appraiser, Liu Mou, also stated that in the record of the investigation made by the Institute, the examiner also stated the dismantling and taking photos in the maintenance of the Hongyun car. The factory was carried out, but according to the dismantling materials provided by Liu, the accident vehicle was not dismantled at the Hongyun repair plant, but was dismantled in Zhao Hai's own auto repair plant. The appraisal and evaluation report records that the location of dismantling and photographing is not in conformity with the real place of dismantling and photographing, and the authenticity of the appraisal report is greatly reduced.
in addition, Zhao Hai argued that the accident vehicle had been repaired in 8 and September 2015 at the Hongyun repair plant, because the factory was no longer open, so the invoice could not be opened. And the maintenance fee of the vehicle must be confirmed by the official invoice, the maintenance list and so on. In the case of no formal invoice, the actual maintenance fee of the vehicle can not be proved to be 54000 yuan. In another appraisal report submitted by Zhao Hai, only the appraiser Liu had stamped the seal without the signature and seal of another identification officer.
the court hereby holds that the appraisal report on which Zhao Hai claims the loss of vehicles was identified by Zhao Hai unilaterally, and the conclusion of the assessment and evaluation report was unfair. After hearing, the Shanghe court submitted a unilateral evaluation report submitted by Zhao Hai to the court, but it did not support the vehicle assessment fee proposed by Zhao Hai on the basis of 1500 yuan. (all parties in the text are the name of the chemical)